Wegner's St. Martins Inn

Loved the fish fry and very friendly staff. Well run front of house.

Like going back in time, to an old fashion Supper Club. The building was build in 1886, and has a history. Great food, and above average service. A real gem.

We had reservations and still waited forever to get seated. I had two total knee replacement's and had to stand for over 40 minutes watching people who came...

Fish was delicious! Went on a Friday night during lent. Waited only 20 min or so at bar. I started with a clam chowder that was very very good. Chowder had Red potatoes, good seasoning, and bits of clam that blended well. On to the fried cod…The fish batter was buttery, seasoned just right, and had excellent texture. The batter complimented the flavors of the cod that was cooked perfectly. The tartar was tangy and well made. Cole slaw had a sweet and creamy taste that melded well with everything else. Also I ordered the German potato salad that was Smokey and sweet. Wait staff was lovely. I highly recommended Wegner’s fish fry.

We've been here a number of times off & on. Perch was so-so, wouldn't order again. Hostess/owner is kinda friendly but if you're not a regular and she doesn't know you personally, she makes you feel unwelcome. The young girl bartender that has been there a long time..is awesome! My partner had fish fry and was okay. Not sure we'll visit Wagner's again.

My third time here & have not walked away disapointed. The food is outstanding, drinks are great & owner & waitstaff top notch. Brings back lots of good memories if my German heritage. Wednesday's are my times to return. Will definitely be returning soon! To everyone try it out you won't be disappointed.

My wife and I have been coming here for years. It has been awhile since our last time with the pandemic and all. We ordered fish fries and picked them up curbside which is really nice. Mine was a perch fry with fries ($18.65) and was really good, my wife had a three piece haddock ($12.75)with potato pancakes and was very disappointed, the pancakes were very hard and the fish was way overcooked, you could see it in the crust and taste it. I could have rated it lower but I know this isn’t the normal for them. We will still go back and give it another go. Sometimes it is better to dine in as you can compliment or complain right away. Perch is on the right.

Our first time here and it was Friday Night Fish Fry. We split the sampler platter and added a bowl of clam chowder. Matt was our server and has worked there for 20 years. That speaks volumes! He said that it is like family there and it did feel very welcoming. We thought the Sampler platter would help us to decide what to have if we came back and it did! Perch and the shrimp were our favorite but the haddock was also very good. All of it was piping hot- nothing lukewarm. And the potato pancake was perfect. We will.be back to try their regular menu!

Wegner’s was recommended to me by some devoted patrons. Glad to find this gem. The Reuben appetizer was fantastic; their German food is delicious. The atmosphere is casual and the customers filled the room with laughter. We were glad to get a last-minute reservation. Though an early reservation was not initially available, the Hostess called us back after someone else cancelled. Great food and wonderful customer service!

Tried the Friday night fish sampler. Shrimp and perch were great. Cod was OK. Scallops were disappointing as the breading overpowered the flavor. Coleslaw was tasty as was the potato pancakes.