My wife ordered two 10in cakes, an Oreo torte and a whipped cream banana cannoli and paid $146. However, the lady on the phone answered as if she was already having a bad day and was rude from the get-go. She kept calling my wife by a different name and couldn't get the order correct. So we had followed up to ensure our order was correct a few days later and it wasn't. It sounded like the same lady picked up again, and she had put down the wrong names on the cakes and order, did not include the extra cannoli, and one of the cakes was a 12in cake instead of 10in.
Once the order was correct, the lady hangs up, even though we were owed a refund b/c they had overcharged us. So we call back and ask to speak to the manager, the same lady picked up again, and didn't want to pass us to a manager and really wanted to know our names. Finally, she did pass us to a manager, who was also rude and she didn't seem to care that the order was wrong nor cared that her employee was rude to us. She said we would get a refund and then hung up.
I called back a few hours later to cancel the order, and this time passed me to a gentleman who was respectful and processed the whole refund within minutes and hit my credit card immediately as well, which makes me wonder why the other refund was taking hours; they probably never passed us to the manager to begin with.
Unfortunately, the past few cakes have been sub-par. My family and I always ask for extra cannoli, but we rarely get it even though we pay for it. We've gotten frozen cakes before, or missing ingredients. These are expensive cakes, however they're not worth the price anymore. My entire family used to buy cakes from this bakery since the 70's but given the price and quality, their cakes are not worth it.
Look elsewhere.